Is It Acceptable to Watch “Rust” After Halyna Hutchins’ Tragic Death?

Alec Baldwin’s controversial Western film "Rust" is set to premiere on May 2, prompting an essential question: Should audiences feel comfortable watching this movie? The film bears a heavy weight, not only as an artistic endeavor but as a poignant reminder of the tragic events that occurred on set during production.

The Tragedy That Haunts "Rust"

On October 21, 2023, the production was rocked by a devastating incident when a prop gun handled by Baldwin discharged a live round, tragically killing Halyna Hutchins, a talented cinematographer, and injuring director Joel Souza. While the scene that led to this tragedy won’t appear in the final film, the specter of Hutchins’ death lingers heavily over its release.

For some viewers, watching "Rust" may feel like an intrusion, a voyeuristic act into a heart-wrenching saga. Others, including Hutchins’ family and colleagues, perceive it as a heartfelt tribute to a talented artist whose work deserves to be honored.

“Halyna’s family knew just how important her art was to her, how much she lived and breathed it,” Souza poignantly remarked.

The Family’s Perspective

Matthew Hutchins, Halyna’s husband, conveyed his gratitude for the support from the producers and the entertainment community. In a statement made in 2023, he expressed his relief at the completion of “Rust,” stating:

"I am grateful that the producers and the entertainment community have come together to pay tribute to Halyna’s final work.”

As part of a wrongful-death settlement, Hutchins was named an executive producer when filming resumed in Montana in 2023, allowing for her legacy to live on through the film.

Supporting Halyna: An Emotional Choice

Rachel Mason, a close friend of Halyna and director of the Hulu documentary "Last Take: Rust and the Story of Halyna," emphasizes how watching "Rust" serves as a means of support for Hutchins’ family:

“By watching the film, you are supporting the family. The money from the film goes to them.”

This sentiment aligns with the decision of many cast and crew members who returned to complete the project, finding purpose in paying tribute to their fallen colleague.

The Art of Halyna Hutchins

Described as at her pinnacle level, Hutchins’ cinematography skills shine through in "Rust." Mason asserts that the film showcases striking visuals, presenting breathtaking wide shots that capture the essence of the Western genre, despite her personal aversion to it:

“I don’t like Westerns at all, but this film is exceptional in many ways.”

The Show Must Go On: Hollywood’s History with Tragedy

Hollywood has faced its share of on-set tragedies, from horrifying accidents to untimely deaths. Productions have often forged ahead to honor the artistic vision, despite the pain involved. Notable examples include:

• "The Twilight Zone" (1982): A horrific helicopter crash resulted in the deaths of actor Vic Morrow and two child actors.
• "The Crow" (1993): The film continued after the tragic death of Brandon Lee, son of Bruce Lee, using special effects to complete the project.

While financial considerations often influence such decisions, the case of "Rust" is more complex, rooted deeply in emotions and the desires of Hutchins’ family.

Conclusion: Should You Watch "Rust"?

As "Rust" prepares to debut, audiences are forced to confront their feelings about the film, balancing the legacy of Halyna Hutchins with the nature of filmmaking itself. With mixed opinions surrounding its release, watching "Rust" offers a unique opportunity for viewers to honor Halyna’s artistry while also engaging with a complex narrative that transcends the screen.

Ultimately, the choice remains with the viewer—whether to immerse themselves in the artistry of a fallen cinematographer or to step back from a film entwined in tragedy.