We Rated 13 Sunscreens for 4 Different Skin Tones: See Our Findings!

As the sun shines brighter each day, the importance of sunscreen becomes undeniably clear. Our goal? To find the best sunscreens suited for various skin tones and types. After careful testing and evaluation, we’ve rated 13 different sunscreens using a comprehensive 1-to-10 scale, focusing on their ability to deliver on their claims, comfort, and, of course, the dreaded white cast.

Table of Contents

• The Importance of Sunscreen
• Testing Methodology
• Top Sunscreens Reviewed
  • 1. Krave Beauty Beet the Sun
  • 2. IT Cosmetics Hello Sunshine Invisible Sunscreen
  • 3. Neutrogena Clear Face Liquid Lotion
  • 4. La Roche-Posay Anthelios Melt-In Sunscreen
  • 5. Vacation Whip Sunscreen
  • 6. Ultra Violette Supreme Screen
  • 7. Youth To The People YouthScreen
  • 8. Hyper Skin Sun Drops
  • 9. Good Weather Skin
  • 10. Shiseido Clear Sunscreen Stick
  • 11. undefined Beauty R&R Sun Elixir
  • 12. Tower 28 SOS FaceGuard
  • 13. Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen
• Conclusion

The Importance of Sunscreen

Sunscreen isn’t just a summer essential—it’s a year-round necessity. Protecting your skin from UV rays can help prevent sunburn, premature aging, and skin cancer. However, not all sunscreens are created equal. Some may leave a white cast on darker skin tones, rendering them ineffective or less appealing. That’s why we’ve rated these products across diverse skin tones to ensure everyone can find their perfect match.

Testing Methodology

To keep things impartial:

1. Skin Tones: We selected four different skin tones to test on.
2. Blind Trials: Products were applied without knowledge of their names or brands.
3. Evaluation Criteria: Each sunscreen was scored based on:
   • White Cast: Does it leave a visible residue?
   • Comfort: How does it feel on the skin?
   • Performance: Does it hold up against heat and sweat?

Top Sunscreens Reviewed

1. Krave Beauty Beet the Sun

Krave Beauty’s Beet the Sun is a fan favorite known for its lightweight feel and no white cast. Once banned in the U.S. for its original formulation, it has been revamped to comply with FDA regulations. The hydrating formula makes it a hit among those with all skin types.

Rating: 10/10

2. IT Cosmetics Hello Sunshine Invisible Sunscreen

This sunscreen does not compromise on hydration. It offers a nourishing feel paired with a tropical scent. While it may be greasy for some, its SPF 50 protection is a significant plus.

Rating: 8/10

3. Neutrogena Clear Face Liquid Lotion

Although marketed as oil-free, this Neutrogena formula left many feeling uncomfortable. Users reported a heavy feeling and a visible white cast, making it less desirable for those with darker skin tones.

Rating: 4/10

4. La Roche-Posay Anthelios Melt-In Sunscreen

While the higher SPF is appealing, this sunscreen didn’t deliver as expected. Many testers found it to feel greasy and heavy, with a noticeable white cast for darker skin.

Rating: 5/10

5. Vacation Whip Sunscreen

This innovative formula felt light and luxurious while offering hydration. Although some described it as slightly greasy, many appreciated its tropical scent and moisturizing properties.

Rating: 8/10

6. Ultra Violette Supreme Screen

Packed with antioxidants, this sunscreen caters well to daily use, especially for those looking for a natural glow. However, some testers found it drying once the initial application settled.

Rating: 9/10

7. Youth To The People YouthScreen

This newly launched sunscreen is a blend of vitamin E and jojoba oil, providing an ultra-hydrating experience. It stood out for delivering a silky feel without the heaviness.

Rating: 9/10

8. Hyper Skin Sun Drops

Designed with darker skin tones in mind, these sun drops felt weightless and provided a glossy finish. Users praised its serum-like texture, although some noted it could be too oily for all-day wear.

Rating: 8/10

9. Good Weather Skin

This mineral sunscreen excelled without the usual chalky residue. Reviewers loved both its chic packaging and effective SPF protection.

Rating: 10/10

10. Shiseido Clear Sunscreen Stick

This easy-to-use stick met the challenge with a pleasant light scent. However, some testers felt it wasn’t as effective under makeup, noting the quick application was best for on-the-go.

Rating: 7/10

11. undefined Beauty R&R Sun Elixir

This luxurious oil left testers feeling glowy and fresh. The serum-like consistency was well-received, but it may not be optimal for oily skin types.

Rating: 9/10

12. Tower 28 SOS FaceGuard

This sunscreen caught attention for being eczema- and acne-friendly. Testers enjoyed the blurring effect, though some expressed dissatisfaction with its tendency to leave a white cast.

Rating: 6/10

13. Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen

A cult favorite, this gel sunscreen blurs imperfections and acts as a great makeup primer. However, some users felt it might flatten their natural glow, leaving a more matte finish.

Rating: 8/10

Conclusion

Finding the right sunscreen shouldn’t feel daunting. With this comprehensive review based on diverse skin tones, you’re equipped to choose the best option for you. Remember, the best sunscreen is the one you’ll wear regularly, so don’t hesitate to try a few and discover what works for your skin!

Ready to gear up for sun protection? Stay safe, stay glowing!