Idaho, We Saved You Money! — A Closer Look at Your Tax Dollars
As the Idaho Legislature wraps up its session, lawmakers return to their districts proclaiming, “Guess what, Idaho? We saved you $292 million this year!” But before you cheer too loudly, let’s dig deeper. The real question is: How much did you actually spend?
A Budget Breakdown: Numbers That Matter
The reported total government spending in Idaho is a staggering $14.1 billion. However, the true figure may shock you—it’s closer to $14.6 billion. Why the discrepancy?
Continuing Spending: The Hidden Costs
Many legislators categorize certain expenditures as “continuing” to avoid placing them on the official budget. These ongoing costs can include essential services and projects that the state consistently funds. By downplaying these expenses, the Legislature obscures the true financial picture. According to our analysis, ignoring this “off-budget” spending could lead to an understatement of around $455 million.
For further insights on Idaho’s budgeting practices, check out this detailed analysis.
Budget Claims vs. Reality: What’s Really Going On?
While the legislators tout a modest 1.5% increase over last year’s spending—claiming it sounds better than it is—the hard reality reveals a more troubling trend. Last year, total spending was $13.9 billion, and this year, it’s projected at $14.6 billion, which is actually a 4.8% increase. This means Idaho spent $669 million more this year than the last, countering claims of significant savings.
Misleading Savings: A Closer Examination
The claim of saving $292 million arises from comparisons to the governor’s budget recommendations, which lack any binding authority. This type of "savings" highlights a significant issue: the Legislature should be accountable to taxpayers, not merely reacting to political benchmarks.
The True Nature of Fiscal Responsibility
To be completely transparent, here’s what we can expect based on recent data:
- Previous year’s full budget: $13.9 billion
- Current year’s projected budget: $14.6 billion
- Overall increase: 4.8%
With $441 million left unallocated for "just in case" scenarios, one must question: Is this prudent fiscal management or a pathway to excess?
Are Your Tax Dollars Safe?
To borrow the words of President Calvin Coolidge, “Collecting more taxes than is absolutely necessary is legalized robbery.” Idaho’s current budgetary practices raise concerns about its commitment to fiscal conservatism. Each year brings increased spending and unspent tax revenues, leading many to feel that their hard-earned dollars are not being managed responsibly.
The Call for Change
Idaho can and should do better. It’s time for lawmakers to prioritize transparency and accountability in budgeting practices. After all, when lawmakers declare savings while actually spending more, the message can feel misleading.
As residents, it’s essential to remain engaged and informed. How do you feel about the state keeping excess of your tax dollars? It’s time for discussions and actions that prioritize the best interests of Idaho families.
In conclusion, let’s hold our legislators accountable—after all, your money deserves better stewardship.
