Unpacking Celine Song’s “Materialists”: An Anti-Rom-Com Experience
Celine Song’s "Materialists", her highly anticipated sophomore feature following the critically acclaimed "Past Lives," dives deep into the murky waters of modern romance. With Dakota Johnson in the lead role, the film offers a refreshing twist on the romantic comedy genre—and it’s anything but conventional.
The Allure of Lucy’s World
In the vibrant yet claustrophobic world of Lucy, the film’s protagonist portrayed by Dakota Johnson, we initially find ourselves enchanted by a lively Manhattan office setting. Here, matchmakers buzz around, celebrating engagements with cheerful toasts and rolling out bar carts—a façade of joy pinned against the bustling reality of a competitive dating landscape.
But as the story unfolds, it becomes apparent that behind the glossy exterior lies a darker truth. The very office that seems glamorous soon reveals its stark limitations: cramped desks collide in an atmosphere reminiscent of a packed nail salon, and the jubilant bar cart sways precariously. Lucy’s sanctuary morphs into a prison of expectations, forcing her to escape to the fire escape for a breath of fresh air—a metaphor for her chaotic emotional life.
More Than Meets the Eye
Though marketed as a rom-com, "Materialists" challenges the very limits of love, a theme seldom probed by traditional romantic films. The film eschews light-heartedness for a cynical exploration of romantic transactions, compelling audiences to reconsider the narrative that love conquers all.
As Celine Song deftly illustrates, love in Lucy’s world is treated as a commodity, reducing emotions to what can be quantified. This commentary is punctuated by dark humor and poignant truths that expose the shallow foundations upon which many romantic tales are built.
Love as a Transaction
Imagine love boiled down to a series of cold calculations—this is where Lucy excels. She treats her clients as mere goods, analyzing compatibility through a clinical lens. Each date is less about connection and more about securing lucrative matches, and as she navigates increasingly absurd setups—women requiring wealth, men seeking youth—her own emotional detachment becomes painfully evident.
A pivotal flashback reveals Lucy’s past with John, played by Chris Evans. Once naïve dreamers in New York City, their love story is overshadowed by financial disparities, unearthing the raw implications of wealth in relationships. The tender moments between them contrast sharply with Lucy’s growing clinical approach to love.
Unexpected Twists and Internal Conflicts
The arrival of Harry, played by Pedro Pascal, ushers in further complications. Harry is both the embodiment of Lucy’s desires and a mirror to her transactional view of love. As their luxurious dates unfold, punctuated by lavish experiences, we witness Lucy grappling with the stark realization: could love surpass mere financial considerations?
The story escalates dramatically, forcing Lucy into a confrontation with her own principles as unpredicted turns upend her carefully constructed world. Faced with a profound upheaval, Lucy must confront the harsh reality that her professional expertise fails to control the unpredictable nature of human emotions.
The Nuances of Choice
As Lucy stands on the precipice of making a pivotal choice between John and Harry, the film forces viewers to contemplate the true essence of love. Is it about wealth or genuine connection? And can those with contrasting views on romance ever find common ground?
Ultimately, "Materialists" isn’t just a journey through the superficiality of dating; it’s an exploration of what makes us human—our desires, our flaws, and our complexities.
Conclusion: A Thought-Provoking Experience
While "Materialists" occasionally leans into familiar tropes of the rom-com genre, Song’s ambition to present a more authentic portrayal of love—filled with grit and moral ambiguity—achieves a compelling resonance.
Celine Song proves she is not merely chronicling love but holding a mirror to its most uncomfortable truths. Viewers should enter this film prepared for a narrative of unexpected introspection, blended with potent commentary on the essence of affection in a commodified world.
Grade: B
Mark your calendars! "Materialists" hits theaters on June 13, courtesy of A24. Don’t miss the chance to engage with this audacious film that examines love beyond the silver screen.
For more critical insights and reviews, explore IndieWire’s film section, or subscribe to our newsletter to stay in the loop on the latest cinematic gems.
