An Engaging Exploration of Queer Identity: She’s the He
Siobhan McCarthy’s charming directorial debut, She’s the He, has captivated audiences since its premiere at the illustrious SXSW Film Festival. This delightful film blends humor and heart as it dives into the complexities of teenage identity and sexuality.
The Plot: Where Humor Meets Heart
The story kicks off with two misfit friends, Alex (Nico Carney) and Ethan (Misha Osherovich), who are determined to change their high school status from "losers" to "legendary." Much like the protagonists of Superbad and Booksmart, their quest is driven by youthful aspirations and comedic situations centered around romance. However, there’s a twist: both boys are seen as gay by their peers, and to alter their reputation, they concoct a plan to come out as transgender.
A Unique Take on Queer Coming-of-Age
While She’s the He follows the traditional beats of a coming-of-age comedy, it boldly subverts expectations. McCarthy, who uses they/them pronouns, has made an intentional choice by casting trans actors to portray cisgender straight men pretending to be trans women. This decision is reminiscent of Shakespeare’s classic Twelfth Night, blending humor with a critical look at gender norms.
The film creates a world where fluid identities are embraced, demonstrating how gender and associated binaries are often socially constructed. As Alex and Ethan navigate their unexpected identities, they do so in an environment that’s unconditionally supportive, offering a refreshing narrative devoid of the heavy trauma often depicted in queer stories.
Satire Amidst Serious Themes
In a time when trans lives face significant threats, She’s the He poignantly tackles these realities through satire. McCarthy cleverly critiques the manufactured fears surrounding transgender individuals, particularly targeting the ridiculous bathroom bills that restrict access to public facilities consistent with one’s gender identity.
However, while this satirical thread is relevant, it sometimes feels underdeveloped; the film’s rapid pacing leaves limited space for deeper commentary. A more substantial exploration of these themes could enhance the overall impact of the narrative.
A Journey of Self-Discovery
The film’s strength lies in its exploration of personal identity. As the story unfolds, it shifts focus to Ethan’s powerful realization of her true self. Initially, what seems to be a reckless plan to woo Sasha (Malia Pyles), a popular girl, evolves into a thoughtful journey of self-exploration and gender identity.
Ethan’s transformation is beautifully depicted through her bonding with Sasha, resulting in moments of genuine joy and self-discovery. With playful cosmetic experiments and heartfelt explorations of femininity, viewers witness a young girl stepping into her authentic self. Osherovich’s performance resonates throughout, particularly in her expressive portrayal of Ethan’s burgeoning confidence and excitement.
Complexities of Teenage Masculinity
Meanwhile, Alex grapples with his notions of masculinity and the external pressures of his father’s expectations. His interactions with cool, nonbinary student Forest (Tatiana Ringsby) introduce insights into how familial approval can distort one’s self-perception. Carney’s portrayal of Alex navigates the intricate dynamics of teenage emotion, evoking sympathy as he searches for his identity amid societal standards.
Yet, the aftermath of their deception brings the narrative to darker territory, leading to betrayal and heartbreak when the truth is revealed to Sasha. McCarthy skillfully depicts these emotional complexities, particularly as other cisgender boys attempt to exploit the same gimmick for less sincere reasons.
A Heartwarming Cinematic Experience
Despite its occasional hiccups, She’s the He delivers a reliably delightful experience. The film features charming supporting roles, including Davis (Mark Indelicato), a flamboyant character who provides crucial lessons about friendship and acceptance.
Visually, the movie flourishes with Leah Morrison’s eclectic costuming and Bethany Michalski’s intimate cinematography, creating a dreamy aesthetic that perfectly encapsulates the essence of adolescence. Even amidst heavier themes, She’s the He exudes a sense of hope and affirmation.
Conclusion: A New Kind of Coming-of-Age Film
In conclusion, Siobhan McCarthy’s She’s the He stands out as a unique addition to the coming-of-age genre. By weaving humor, poignant self-discovery, and social commentary, the film cultivates a narrative that resonates deeply with audiences. As it champions individuality and kindness, She’s the He is a must-see for anyone navigating the vibrant complexities of identity.
For more insights into LGBTQ+ cinema, check out these resources from The Advocate and Variety.
