Movie Review: Alec Baldwin’s Controversial Western Rust Finally Makes Its Debut
After a long journey through tragedy and turmoil, Rust is available for audiences to explore on various streaming platforms. While the film carries a dark cloud of controversy, it offers a surprising depth that fans of the Western genre will appreciate.
A Deep Dive into Rust
Rating: 7 out of 10
Genre: Western Drama
Running Time: 2 hours 19 minutes
Directed by: Joel Souza
Starring: Alec Baldwin, Patrick Scott McDermott, Travis Fimmel, Josh Hopkins, Frances Fisher
Availability: Rent and stream on various PVOD services
A Tragic Backstory Shapes the Film’s Release
Rust has been anything but ordinary. The film gained worldwide notoriety following a tragic incident on set in 2023, where cinematographer Halyna Hutchins lost her life due to a prop guns mishap. This heartbreaking event brought production to a standstill for over a year, prompting extensive investigations and legal battles.
Despite carrying the weight of this tragedy, Rust now stands as a testament to resilience in the face of adversity. The question remains: can it be appreciated as a cinematic work separate from its infamous backstory?
The Plot Unfolds: A Fresh Take on the Western Genre
In Rust, director Joel Souza navigates the landscape of early America, focusing not merely on the well-known face of Alec Baldwin but bringing to light the character of 13-year-old Lucas Hollister, brilliantly portrayed by Patrick Scott McDermott. Lucas, thrust into the role of guardian for his younger brother following a family tragedy, becomes embroiled in a web of conflict when an accidental killing leads to a death sentence.
Rescued by his grandfather, Harland Rust (Baldwin), the pair embark on a perilous journey to evade the law, blending familial bonds with the classic outlaw narrative.
A Bond Like No Other: The Grandfather-Grandson Dynamic
The relationship between Lucas and Harland gives Rust its emotional core, setting it apart from typical Westerns. This dynamic resonates with viewers, reminiscent of the underappreciated film News of the World featuring Tom Hanks. Baldwin captures both warmth and ferocity, but it is McDermott’s performance that truly steals the spotlight, showcasing a young man forced to muster courage in the face of brutal realities—a fundamental trait of great American Westerns.
Strengths and Weaknesses: An Honest Assessment
Souza’s script is marked by compelling dialogue, though it occasionally falters under the weight of multiple subplots involving those hunting down Lucas and Harland. At times, the pacing drags, particularly in the second act, making the film feel longer than it needs to be. Nonetheless, the beautiful landscapes and stunning cinematography—initially helmed by Hutchins and continued by Bianca Cline—add a visual spectacle that elevates the viewing experience.
Breathtaking Cinematic Landscapes
One of the most striking features of Rust is its cinematography. Each frame encapsulates the beauty of the Western landscape, creating an immersive viewing experience that deserves a large screen. The vivid portrayal of nature serves to enhance the film’s emotional impact.
The Moral Dilemma: To Watch or Not to Watch?
The release of Rust raises ethical questions about supporting a production with such a haunting history. It is essential to recognize that all profits from the film will go towards benefiting Hutchins’ family, as legally mandated by the producers. This aspect may offer some solace to those grappling with the film’s dark past.
In a poignant moment early in the film, Harland imparts wisdom to his grandson, stating, “There’s alive and there’s ain’t. Try to focus on the former.” This theme of making the most of one’s circumstances resonates throughout the movie, reflecting not only the narrative but also the filmmakers’ commitment to honoring Hutchins’ memory.
Final Thoughts: A Compelling Watch
Despite its troubled inception, Rust emerges as a work worthy of attention. With its engaging characters, stunning visuals, and a narrative that tugs at the heart, it transcends the tragic events surrounding its production. If you’re curious to see how Souza and his team navigated such immense challenges, don’t miss the opportunity to experience Rust—a film that is as much about survival as it is about reflection.
Watch the trailer here and discover this unique take on the Western genre that’s finally ready for audiences to embrace.
