Mr. Burton Film Review: Richard Burton’s Origin Story Settles for Safety
In the world of biopics, “Mr. Burton” stands as a compelling yet timid portrayal of the life of Richard Burton, focusing primarily on the influential figure of Philip Burton rather than the celebrated actor himself. Philip Burton—masterfully portrayed by Toby Jones—was not merely a mentor; he was a pivotal figure in shaping young Richard’s (played by Harry Lawtey) path from the gritty coal mines of Port Talbot, Wales, to the glittering heights of global stardom.
The Complexity of Mentorship
The narrative takes us on a journey through the intricacies of mentorship, leveraging hints from classics like “Pygmalion” and “Henry IV Part II.” In this tale, Philip is akin to Henry Higgins, a quirky blend of a rejected Falstaff and a Dr. Frankenstein figure, struggling with his desire to nurture while battling the fear of losing his prized creation.
Toby Jones breathes life into Philip with a poignant, nuanced performance that reveals the layers of ambition and passion within a seemingly stiff exterior. His declaration—“A cultured person is never lonely”—clashes amusingly with his character’s loneliness, painting him as a complex Svengali figure who straddles admiration and control.
The Transformation of Richard Burton
Harry Lawtey brings a youthful intensity to Richard Burton’s character, capturing the essence of a young man plagued with insecurities and aspirations. While he skillfully portrays the initial awkwardness and raw talent of the future star, moments of exaggerated mannerisms, such as his unintentional resemblance to Ben Stiller’s “Blue Steel” in “Zoolander,” somewhat detract from the character’s authenticity. However, the evolution of Richie is compelling to watch: his transformation into the bold, erratic persona that the world eventually recognizes as Richard Burton is both intriguing and thrilling.
The Film’s Missed Opportunities
Despite its insightful moments, "Mr. Burton" often plays it too safe. The film lightly touches on Richard’s inner turmoil, grappling with guilt over abandoning his humble origins and the complexities of his sexual identity, showcased bluntly through confrontations with his barroom bully of a father. However, exploration of these themes feels surface-level and lacks the depth that would resonate more profoundly with viewers.
Directed by Marc Evans, the film’s visuals also evoke a sense of cautiousness through its “discrete taupe palette.” While this choice effectively preserves the somber tone of the 1940s setting, it results in a too-sterilized environment that diminishes the gritty authenticity of the narrative. Rather than evoking the era’s true struggles, the film sometimes resembles an overly polished reproduction, akin to a decorative print hanging in a bed-and-breakfast.
Supporting Characters Make Their Mark
Lesley Manville offers a subtle yet supportive performance as Philip’s landlady. Despite the limitations of her role, encapsulated in the line “Let me make you some tea,” she delivers with an elegance that feels underutilized. Meanwhile, Jones navigates Philip’s self-doubt and introspective qualities with finesse, showcasing the often-unspoken battle faced by those behind the scenes of greatness.
Conclusion: A Cautious Exploration
In conclusion, “Mr. Burton” presents a misaligned narrative that could have delved deeper into the rich psychological landscape of both Philip and Richard Burton. While it successfully highlights the power of mentorship and artistic ambition, it ultimately pulls back from fully realizing the dark complexities and suspicions surrounding success, leaving audiences with a beautifully crafted yet somewhat bland experience.
Rating: ★★☆☆☆
Catch "Mr. Burton" in cinemas from April 4, and embark on this cautionary tale about the price of fame and the shadows cast by whimsical mentorship.
For those interested in a deeper dive into biographical films, check out this analysis on the significance of mentorship in cinema.
