How the MAHA Food Agenda Risks Setting Women Back Decades
In today’s food landscape, the MAHA Food Agenda looms large, raising critical questions about its impact on women and society at large. As we navigate this complex issue, it’s essential to explore how regulatory decisions affect our food choices and the roles women play in the kitchen—and beyond.
The Case for Comprehensive Regulation
In the ever-expanding world of processed foods, there is a growing consensus that more stringent oversight is necessary. Dr. MacKendrick emphasizes that we need a robust government-regulated system to review what is sprayed on or added to our food. This would entail greater oversight from the FDA and EPA—an approach starkly contrary to current deregulatory trends.
According to Marion Nestle, PhD, a renowned molecular biologist and professor of nutrition and public health at NYU, the recent MAHA initiative to ban certain food dyes is merely "low-hanging fruit." It’s far easier to target individual components rather than confront the more extensive health concerns surrounding ultra-processed foods (UPFs) that dominate our diets.
Challenging Corporate Influence
To mitigate the pervasive impact of UPFs, experts suggest regulating corporate lobbying within the food industry. Dr. Knurick advocates for restrictions that would also limit misleading marketing strategies from food manufacturers. Dr. Zeide concurs, stating that untangling nutrition research from Big Food’s financial grip would enable scientists to create processed foods that are not only cost-effective but also genuinely healthy—not just addictively tasty.
Shifting the Subsidy Structure
Another pressing consideration for the MAHA commission is the financial landscape of food production. By reallocating government subsidies from corn and soybeans—key ingredients in many UPFs—to fresh fruits and vegetables, we could shift the economic incentives toward healthier eating. Federal grants could empower farms to provide fresh produce to local schools and food banks, echoing Biden-era initiatives that have been jeopardized by previous administrations.
Redefining Women’s Roles
At the core of this discussion is the burden of homemaking, which still disproportionately falls on women. While many women take pride in cooking and growing food, we must be cautious about promoting these roles as essential for family health. The MAHA agenda risks perpetuating a narrative that encourages women to engage in unpaid labor, undermining their autonomy and professional opportunities.
This echoes patterns observed during the Trump administration, where policy decisions jeopardized women’s rights and health, pulling funds from vital family planning services. Instead, we need a paradigm shift towards policies like national paid leave and subsidized childcare that empower women to balance motherhood with their professional aspirations.
Navigating the Food Landscape: Practical Advice
As we grapple with these complex issues, what can you do to ensure your family’s nutritional needs are met? Strive for a thoughtful balance between whole and processed foods. If you have the means, consider growing a garden, but also support local farmers directly whenever you can. And remember: there’s no need to feel guilty about purchasing fresh produce from grocery stores—it’s often the most practical and equitable choice in today’s world.
Processed and ultra-processed foods serve essential roles in many households, offering convenience and even occasional joy. As Dr. Levinovitz wisely states, we must resist binary thinking: “It’s not good and evil, pure and impure.” Embracing the complexity of our food choices allows for a richer understanding of what it means to eat well in an imperfect world.
Get Involved and Stay Informed
For those passionate about food justice and women’s rights, staying informed is key. Consider subscribing to informative resources that keep you updated on the latest in nutrition and food policy.
Related:
Get more of SELF’s great service journalism delivered right to your inbox.
Photographer: Ian Loring Shiver
Prop Stylist: Kelsi Windmiller
As we look to the future of our food system, it’s clear: engagement, awareness, and advocacy are crucial for steering the conversation toward a more equitable and healthy landscape for all.
