Rami Malek Delivers a Riveting Performance in ‘The Amateur’: A Satisfying Spy Thriller with Some Twists and Turns
Now Streaming On: JustWatch
Overview of ‘The Amateur’
In The Amateur, CIA data analyst Charlie Heller, played convincingly by Rami Malek, embarks on a reckless journey of vengeance after a devastating personal loss. Set against a backdrop of international espionage, this film opens in Prague and will soon be available in cinemas worldwide. Directed by James Hawes, the espionage thriller offers some dazzling visuals but falters under the weight of its convoluted plot.
A Tale of Revenge and Espionage
Adapted from Robert Littell’s 1981 novel, The Amateur brings a fresh perspective to a storied tale, having previously been adapted into a film featuring John Savage and Christopher Plummer. Littell, known for his intricate spy narratives, initially wove a story that kept viewers on their toes. However, both this latest adaptation and its predecessor struggle to find a coherent balance between thriller and revenge narrative.
Exploring the Plot
In 2025’s The Amateur, Malek’s character, Charlie Heller, is devastated when his loving wife, Sarah (played by Rachel Brosnahan), is killed in a terrorist attack in London. Seeking justice, he finds himself at odds with his superiors at Langley, including Deputy Director Alex Moore (portrayed by Holt McCallany) and agent Caleb (Danny Sapani), who offer little more than distant sympathy.
Determined to take matters into his own hands, Charlie devises a plan both daring and dangerous: he blackmails the CIA into transforming him into an assassin, embarking on a mission to eliminate those responsible for his wife’s death. Laurence Fishburne is compelling as Henderson, the unwitting officer tasked with recruiting Charlie while contemplating the fallout from this risky gambit.
What Works and What Doesn’t
The film’s setup introduces a classic revenge trope; however, it quickly stumbles when the motivations behind Charlie’s actions become muddled. In the source material, the essence of blackmail serves as a compelling plot point, though in this version, it’s clarified too early. Charlie’s discovery of documents implicating Moore in murky conspiracies detracts from the film’s adherence to its central theme of vengeance.
Moreover, the film raises questions that aren’t fully explored—such as its implication of a deep-seated corruption within the CIA—as Charlie ventures into the underbelly of Europe. Rather than rooting for Charlie’s dark path to justice, viewers may find themselves detached from his cold execution of revenge. By the time he reaches his final target, played by Michael Stuhlbarg, audiences might be left wondering if the journey was ever justified.
Malek’s Performance Shines Amidst a Flawed Script
Despite the script’s shortcomings, Malek shines brightly as the driven analyst. His portrayal of Charlie Heller captures the character’s internal struggle with guilt and the moral complexities of revenge. Under the direction of Hawes, who previously helmed the acclaimed Slow Horses on Apple TV+ and the poignant biopic One Life, the film boasts striking visuals and moments of tension, particularly in a breathtaking pool scene that showcases Malek’s talents.
The Verdict: A Missed Opportunity
Ultimately, The Amateur falls short of its potential and the narrative depth found in Littell’s original work. Its failure to capitalize on compelling villains and a coherent storyline leaves it feeling disjointed. While the film includes thrilling action and some engaging moments, it lacks a meaningful exploration of revenge’s consequences. The original 1981 adaptation had its flaws, but this retelling accentuates them rather than providing clarity or improvement.
If you’re drawn to gritty spy thrillers or are a fan of Rami Malek’s work, perhaps give The Amateur a watch. However, be prepared—this mission may not deliver the satisfaction you seek.
Final Thoughts
The Amateur serves as a reminder that even with top-tier talent and a captivating premise, execution is paramount. For viewers hoping for a gripping tale of vengeance and espionage, it might be best to seek out more fulfilling alternatives in the genre.
For more reviews and deep dives into the latest movies, explore our archives and keep up with the cinematic world!
