Rep. Ritchie Torres Calls for Inquiry into Park Slope Food Co-op’s Alleged Antisemitism
The vibrant aisles of the Park Slope Food Co-op, a beloved institution in Brooklyn, are currently shadowed by serious allegations of antisemitism and discrimination. Bronx Congressman Ritchie Torres ignited a firestorm this week, urging both the city and state officials to conduct a thorough investigation into claims of a hostile environment for Jews and supporters of Israel within this community-oriented grocery store.
A Demand for Accountability
On Friday, Rep. Torres sent out impactful letters to NYC Mayor Eric Adams, Governor Kathy Hochul, and other key figures, spotlighting what he describes as "an insidious pattern of harassment and intimidation." Torres insists that anti-discrimination laws must be enforced with unwavering rigor, emphasizing the critical need for a fair investigation to protect marginalized members.
“Anti-discrimination laws must be rigorously and impartially enforced — without exception,” Torres asserted.
Background of Controversy
Historically, the Park Slope Food Co-op has engaged in heated debates over international issues, particularly concerning Israel and Palestine. A notorious vote in 2012, where members rejected a motion to boycott Israeli products, famously drew the attention of The Daily Show due to the uproar it generated (source).
However, following the recent Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023, tensions have escalated. Reports indicate that the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement’s supporters are gaining influence in the co-op’s leadership, creating polarizing dynamics within what was once a united community.
Witness Accounts Reveal Disturbing Incidents
Zara Watkins, a co-op member who vocally opposes the BDS movement, recounted a deeply unsettling experience from Halloween last year. Donning a costume that paid homage to Sabra hummus, she found herself encircled by hostile members who verbally attacked her for her support of Israeli products.
“It really shook me up,” she stated, indicating that her concerns were dismissed by the co-op’s resolution committee.
Ramon Maislen, another Jewish member and advocate for Israel, expressed his dismay following his defeat in a board election against the pro-BDS faction. He claims that he faced repeated verbal abuse during his attempts to foster dialogue and understanding among members.
“We feel let down by the co-op’s leadership,” said Maislen, who leads a political action committee dedicated to challenging anti-Israel rhetoric in local politics.
Allegations of Hate Speech
Maislen has also submitted his own complaint to the state Human Rights Division, detailing incidents where pro-BDS participants allegedly hurled Nazi slogans at Jewish members, along with vile comments like they “smell of Palestinian blood.” The pending investigation underscores the seriousness of these allegations.
Responses from Co-op Leadership
While representatives from the Park Slope Food Co-op Members for Palestine remained unavailable for comments, they expressed their justification for a boycott on Israeli products as an act of solidarity against perceived injustices in Palestine.
Joe Holtz, co-founder of the co-op, maintains that the organization stands against any form of discrimination but chose not to elaborate on the specific allegations, further complicating the narrative.
Looking Ahead: A Review in Progress
In light of these troubling developments, city officials are preparing to delve deeper into the unfolding situation.
A spokesperson for Mayor Adams emphasized the urgency: “Far too often we see antisemitic propaganda masquerading as activism, leading to an unacceptable rise in antisemitism. This is painfully evident in incidents at the Park Slope Food Co-op.”
Governor Hochul’s office echoed similar sentiments, reiterating her long-standing commitment to combating antisemitism, yet refrained from commenting on ongoing investigations.
Conclusion: A Community at a Crossroads
As the situation within the Park Slope Food Co-op continues to evolve, it raises critical questions about inclusivity and safety in community spaces. The co-op, known for its unique structure requiring members to contribute labor in exchange for discounted groceries, now faces an identity crisis that could redefine its values.
Will the Park Slope Food Co-op manage to reconcile its internal conflicts, or will these divisions lead to a permanent rift within this once-tight-knit community? The next few weeks are likely to be crucial in determining the future of this cherished institution.
