A Haunting Exploration of Conscience: "Small Things Like These" Movie Review
The film "Small Things Like These," directed by Tim Mielants, bravely delves into one of Ireland’s darkest chapters. Based on Claire Keegan’s powerful 2023 novella, the story unfolds between 1765 and 1998, when thousands of young Irish women were imprisoned in the notorious Magdalene laundries. These institutions became a prison for the so-called "fallen women," subjecting them to abuse and relentless labor as a supposed form of penance for societal sins like prostitution, promiscuity, or unwed pregnancies.
A Unique Perspective on a Troubling History
Meet Bill Furlong: A Reluctant Hero
Cillian Murphy portrays Bill Furlong, a coal merchant and devoted family man. As he goes about his deliveries in a quaint yet oppressive Irish town, he inadvertently becomes a witness to the grave injustices occurring at the local convent. Bill’s background as the child of a single mother raised by a benevolent local figure instills in him a unique empathy for the girls trapped in the laundries—a stark contrast to the muted horror experienced by many of his neighbors, who fear their own social standing more than seeking justice.
A Gripping but Subtle Narrative
"Small Things Like These" resists the urge to become a straightforward allegory about Ireland’s growing awareness of church abuses. Instead, Mielants prioritizes character development, ensuring that viewers deeply engage with Bill’s internal struggle. This focus transforms the film into a gripping psychological drama, almost evoking the chilling atmosphere of a haunting horror film.
Set amidst the grim realities of 1980s Ireland during the winter holidays, the film is intentionally devoid of typical festive cheer. With creaking doors, hushed voices, and unsparing shadows, Mielants paints a picture that is as bleak as it is gripping.
The Masterclass of Cillian Murphy
Murphy delivers a powerhouse performance, infusing Bill Furlong with complexities that resonate. The depths of Bill’s torment are palpable—his midnight wanderings, his silent sympathy for the impoverished, and the weight of his decisions hang heavily. When he finally resolves to act against the injustices he witnesses, the moment lacks dramatic fanfare but resonates with authenticity.
Emily Watson’s Riveting Performance
In a brief yet pivotal role as the mother superior of the convent, Emily Watson brings an unsettling edge to the character. Her seemingly innocent fireside chat is tinged with menace, akin to Count Orlock’s eerie introduction in the recent adaptation of Nosferatu. Watson’s portrayal adds layers of tension that leave viewers on edge.
Why It Might Not Be For Everyone
"Small Things Like These" may not cater to mainstream audiences; its minimalist narrative, sharp dialogue, and deliberate pacing diverge from conventional blockbuster formulas. However, it’s precisely this approach that creates a thought-provoking drama that immerses the viewer into the psychological landscape of its protagonist with remarkable precision.
Final Thoughts
In conclusion, Tim Mielants offers a profound meditation on conscience, guilt, and courage through "Small Things Like These." This film stands as a testimony to the enduring impact of historical atrocities while exploring the fine line between complicity and empathy. Cillian Murphy’s unforgettable performance, coupled with the haunting atmosphere Mielants creates, assures that this film leaves a lasting impression—one that compels audiences to confront uncomfortable truths about society and its past.
For those interested in a thought-provoking cinematic experience, "Small Things Like These" is a journey worth embarking upon, albeit one that challenges the heart and stirs the soul.
