The question of why a Sydney Sweeney film isn’t receiving a wide theatrical release lingers as we delve into the emotional landscape of Echo Valley (now streaming on Apple TV+). Is it due to the declining appeal of mid-budget films geared towards adults? Or perhaps it’s because Sweeney, in this outing, shares the screen with the phenomenal Julianne Moore, who, while remarkable, lacks major box-office clout. Alternatively, could it signify a lack of confidence from distributors in a film that, let’s face it, has its share of flaws? Any of these explanations might hold water. Directed by Michael Pearce (whom you might know from Encounter) and scripted by Brad Ingelsby—the talent behind HBO’s gripping Mare of Easttown—this film boasts a strong cast and promising team. Yet it struggles to rise to the heights one might expect from such talent. Still, it may warrant a watch.
ECHO VALLEY: STREAM IT OR SKIP IT?
The Gist: Let’s set the record straight: this is NOT a Sydney Sweeney bathing suit movie. In fact, Echo Valley flips the script, showcasing Sweeney as a deeply troubled character—a drug addict who is far from glamorous, complete with a lackluster wardrobe and a complex emotional landscape that prompts us to ponder our feelings toward her. If you’re worried this serious drama doesn’t fully engage with its heavy themes, well, you might be onto something. The film seems more invested in its plot mechanics than in deeply exploring its characters. Yet, it serves up a plot that’s intriguing enough to keep watching.
Plot Overview: The narrative kicks off with Kate Garrett (played by Moore), immersed in her own turmoil after the unexpected passing of her wife. Alone on the farm, struggling to care for horses and bills alike, Kate’s grief is palpable as she listens to warm voicemails from her late partner. She attempts to connect with her professional life but frequently cancels riding lessons due to overwhelming sadness. Enter her daughter Claire (Sweeney), a chaotic presence whose claims of sobriety trigger skepticism in Kate. Amidst her own struggles, Kate is a devoted mother, tirelessly funding Claire’s numerous stints in rehab, even as the thin line between enabling and tough love begins to blur.
What Movies Will It Remind You Of?
Echo Valley evokes an almost supernatural, true-crime essence reminiscent of Stephen King’s works, particularly films like Dolores Claiborne and A Good Marriage.
Performance Worth Watching
Let’s be candid: while Sweeney delivers a solid performance, the film is ultimately carried by the undeniable strength of Moore. One might argue that this role was more suited for an actress like Julia Garner, yet Moore’s stature elevates Echo Valley significantly.
Memorable Dialogue
In a heartfelt moment, Kate humorously comforts a struggling mother on the beach:
Random Mom: Tell me it gets easier!
Kate: Oh god, no. Just you wait. (A pregnant pause, as the mom’s face darkens) I’m just kidding. Every day is a gift.
Sex and Skin
None.
Our Take
Echo Valley delves into its fraught mother-daughter relationship, navigating the delicate balance between enabling and tough love. As the plot thickens, Ingelsby delivers a compelling twist that complicates Kate and Claire’s dynamics even further, paving the way for a resolution that might stretch credulity but remains engrossing. The film culminates in a gripping confrontation featuring Moore and the menacing Gleeson, transforming familial sacrifice into something more action-packed.
Despite its flaws, Echo Valley stirs up entertainment value, relying on Moore’s masterful performance to mitigate its uneven moments. Pearce successfully builds a sense of tension, using the eerie rural setting and a seemingly idyllic lake that morphs into an ominous presence after dark. It’s a classic instance of a subpar screenplay struggling to match the nuanced acting but, against the odds, still captivating viewers.
Our Call: Echo Valley is a mixed bag, likely requiring a bit of audience forgiveness. Personally, I found enough heart in the chaos to recommend it. So, go ahead: STREAM IT!
John Serba is a freelance writer and film critic based in Grand Rapids, Michigan.
