Why Experimentation Is Essential for Brands in 2025
Liam Wade – Performance Director at Performance Marketing Agency, Impression.
As we stride into **2025**, the greatest peril in marketing isn’t about making audacious moves; it’s about playing it too safe. In a world where **AI-driven tools** are quickening the pace of innovation, they also unintentionally pave the way for a **competitive stalemate**. When every brand utilizes the same software and strategies, the quest for differentiation becomes a daunting challenge.
In my discussions with over ten new brands each week, a staggering **90% express** a universal concern: what was once considered “tried and tested” now yields diminishing returns. Some blame fickle algorithms, while others acknowledge their own cautiousness in approaching marketing.
This situation creates the “edge gap”—the widening chasm between brands that aim for efficiency and those that are willing to explore **effectiveness**. Closing this gap requires a fundamental mindset shift: **view experimentation as a strategic advantage** rather than an optional tactic.
Defining the Edge Gap
Marketing in 2025 unfolds under a stark realization: **uniformity reigns supreme**. While Meta’s Advantage+ campaigns skyrocketed to a staggering $20 billion annual run rate in Q4 2024, 95% of retail marketers embraced Google’s Performance Max according to Tinuiti’s Q4 2024 Benchmark Report.
These statistics indicate more than mere trends; they signify a marketing landscape that has become **bland and indistinct**.
The edge gap becomes evident as brands cling to automated, **AI-driven** systems, sacrificing creativity for the sake of efficiency. Consequently, those who venture beyond the conventional practices actively seek paths that set them apart.
This gap signifies the difference between marketing strategies that sharpen a brand’s competitive edge and those dulled by the repetitive, algorithmic approach prevalent in the industry.
Exploration vs. Iteration
Many brands mistakenly believe they are innovating when in fact, they are merely fine-tuning their strategies. Adjusting creative assets or trimming unnecessary expenses might enhance ROI, but these efforts are mere optimizations, not true explorations.
**Exploration** demands stepping off the beaten path—testing unconventional ideas, experimenting with unique channels, and boldly playing with creative formats. These pursuits often raise eyebrows but can yield invaluable insights.
However, iteration is perceived as a safer option, often leading to quick wins that gain approval from stakeholders. The downside? Overemphasizing what already works results in limited exploration and ultimately weakens long-term growth. To achieve **real progress**, brands must adopt a **systematic approach to experimentation**.
The Antidote: Experimentation
**Experimentation** emerges as the antidote to an overly cautious marketing environment. It empowers brands to test daring ideas without risking their entire budget. It is a comprehensive system for learning and **measuring** performance before scaling, allowing teams to challenge conventional boundaries with confidence.
While high risks can yield significant rewards, experimentation helps mitigate these risks by validating parts of the strategy prior to full-scale investment. This gives teams the liberty to pursue **genuine innovation** without the fear of immediate backlash.
The **upside** of a strong experimental culture is well-documented. Bain & Company showcases numerous instances where marketing experimentation led to remarkable ROI growth. Nevertheless, a McKinsey report reveals that only 25% of C-level marketers have genuinely embedded a test-and-learn culture into their teams.
This gap isn’t about a lack of knowledge; it’s a matter of commitment. Often, data analytics teams are more focused on validating existing strategies rather than **pursuing** new ones.
Experimentation alters this paradigm by using data as a launchpad for future success, not solely as a rearview mirror.
Building a Culture of Experimentation
While it’s easy to advocate for experimentation, embedding it into the core fabric of your team is a daunting task. High-performing brands typically exhibit three fundamental traits:
1. Bravery
These brands reward innovation and protect teams venturing into the unknown. Failure is an integral component of discovery. At Impression, some of our standout campaigns originated from ambitious experiments. True creative evolution necessitates strong leadership support for **bold testing**—both financially and culturally.
2. Selective Patience
Not every idea warrants testing, and not all experiments yield immediate gains. Effective teams identify high-impact hypotheses that have the potential to unlock substantial growth. Rushing conclusions often leads to superficial results that are discarded prematurely; genuine learning requires dedication and time.
3. Scientific Rigor
A structured approach is vital for credible testing. Ambiguous or biased experiments create confusion rather than clarity. Rigorous data science practices are non-negotiable, entailing clear hypotheses and controlled variables to ensure significant results before deeming them successful.
Successful teams view experimentation as a perpetual learning system, not a series of isolated projects.
Why Safe is the New Risky
In a marketing realm increasingly dominated by black-box automation and AI, many have been tempted to alter their objectives to fit the platform’s **best practices**.
However, when everyone follows the same framework, **best practices** devolve into **common practices**.
Stagnation equates to decline.
Experimentation transcends tactical addition; it’s a vital **cultural mindset** that empowers your brand to navigate the landscape swiftly while avoiding the traps of uniformity. This approach allows you to explore the unconventional and discover the breakthroughs that can set you apart from the competition.
As we progress through this dynamic decade, the edge gap will continue to expand, distinguishing those brands unwilling to take risks from those that capitalize on growth.
Consider yourself fortunate if you’re currently thriving under traditional practices. However, that comfort is precarious. Soon enough, an innovative competitor will rise in your market space, willing to challenge the status quo.
One type of brand will settle for iteration, while another embraces exploration. Only one will secure its future.
Forbes Communications Council is an invitation-only community for executives in successful public relations, media strategy, creative and advertising agencies. Do I qualify?
