Exploring Depths: A Review of "Titan: The OceanGate Disaster"
Mark Monroe’s "Titan: The OceanGate Disaster" may be grounded in a tragedy that unfolded just over a year ago, but its insights resonate deeply, making it a compelling watch for true-crime enthusiasts and casual viewers alike. This Netflix documentary is not just another macabre retelling of a shocking event but a thoughtfully researched exploration of both human ambition and hubris.
A Film that Stirs Controversy
Unlike the quick-turnaround documentaries often seen on platforms like Hulu, which cover recent tragedies for shock value, "Titan" stands as a meticulously crafted piece, infused with profound questions about risk and responsibility. The documentary navigates the complexities surrounding the 2023 OceanGate disaster, where Stockton Rush and four other passengers lost their lives when their submersible imploded on its trek to the Titanic wreck.
A Race Against Time
The story began capturing media attention long before the confirmation of the tragedy, highlighting society’s insatiable curiosity for dramatic narratives. In a world where news cycles are rapid and relentless, this documentary arrives at a time when memories of the event remain fresh, yet it also underscores a shocking sense of déjà vu in our collective consciousness.
Caught in the Web of Celebrity Culture
Monroe crafts a narrative that positions the disaster as a cautionary tale about celebrity culture and the dangers of idolizing charismatic figures. The presence of tech moguls like Elon Musk adds layers of contemporary relevance, while also serving to remind viewers of our societal inclination to overlook warning signs in the face of charismatic leadership.
Diving into the Abyss
Although "Titan" could offer a deeper plunge into the emotional ramifications of the tragedy, it captures the crux of Rush’s philosophy as he recklessly prioritizes ambition over safety. Archive footage throughout the film attests to Rush’s arrogance as he dismisses safety protocols with statements like: “If you hear an alarm, don’t worry about it.” These chilling reassurances echo through the narrative and serve to heighten the sense of foreboding.
A Pincer Structure: Past and Present Collide
Monroe’s storytelling technique takes a unique approach by juxtaposing the early developments of OceanGate with the congressional hearings following the implosion. This dynamic structure emphasizes the inevitability of the disaster while simultaneously showcasing Rush’s unchecked ego.
Underwhelming Focus on Victims
While the documentary excels in analyzing Rush’s motivations and failures, it notably glosses over the individuals onboard the Titan. While sensitivity towards their families is essential, their perspectives remain largely unaddressed, hampering the emotional depth the film aims to achieve. The inclusion of Paul-Henri Nargeolet’s daughter offers a poignant moment, yet the focus on the victims feels insufficient.
A Company Built on Charisma
The film astutely observes how OceanGate reflected its founder’s larger-than-life persona. Rush, much like Steve Jobs with Apple, intertwined his identity with the company. This symbiosis complicates critiques of OceanGate’s failures as they inherently also become critiques of Rush himself.
"Titan" serves to unveil how public fascination with innovation can overshadow critical safety practices, making viewers question whether we’re witnessing a repeat of history in various domains today.
Final Thoughts: A Cautionary Tale
While “Titan: The OceanGate Disaster” offers a robust account of the events leading to this societal tragedy, it ultimately leaves viewers with a bittersweet taste. The documentary is engaging but could delve deeper into who Stockton Rush was beyond his corporate exterior.
Grade: C
"Titan: The OceanGate Disaster" premiered at the 2025 Tribeca Festival and will be available for streaming on Netflix starting Wednesday, June 11. This film raises pertinent questions about the cultural forces that drive individuals to mistake ambition for capability.
For more in-depth film reviews, consider checking out IndieWire’s reviews and subscribe to In Review for exclusive insights from top critics.
