“The Penguin Lessons” (111 min, Rated PG-13 for strong language, some sexual references, some violence, and thematic elements) – 7 out of 10
A Heartwarming and Humorous Tale Set Against a Backdrop of Turmoil
When I first heard about "The Penguin Lessons," a film depicting an extraordinary bond between a human and a penguin against a South American backdrop, I couldn’t help but draw a parallel to last year’s charming film, "My Penguin Friend," starring Jean Reno. While both films celebrate the heartwarming tale of a penguin rescued from peril, their narratives unfold across different times and places, infusing each with unique emotional layers.
Set in Argentina in 1976, "The Penguin Lessons" is a true story inspired by Tom Michell’s memoirs, detailing the incredible relationship formed between a schoolteacher and his avian friend, all while a country grapples with political upheaval.
A Story of Love and Loss Amidst Political Chaos
The film, directed by Peter Cattaneo and adapted by screenwriter Jeff Pope, expertly juxtaposes endearing moments with the stark realities of a nation in crisis. Tom Michell, played by the acclaimed Steve Coogan, steps into a tumultuous period of his life, taking on a job to teach English at a prestigious all-boys school near Buenos Aires. Despite his initial reluctance, this job morphs into a transformative adventure, thanks to an unexpected friend—a Magellan penguin.
The Penguin’s Arrival: A Turning Point
During a fateful weekend escape from the rigidity of his school environment, Tom stumbles upon an oil-slicked penguin on the beach. Rejecting the call of the sea, this spirited penguin, affectionately named Juan Salvador, follows Tom back to the school, leading to a heartwarming yet comedic series of events that breathe life into Tom’s otherwise mundane existence.
As he slyly smuggles his newfound friend into the confines of the school, Tom’s interactions with staff and students evolve, infusing him with hope and camaraderie. The penguin becomes an unexpected school mascot, spreading joy even among the sternest of staff members, including the intimidating headmaster portrayed masterfully by Jonathan Pryce.
The Balance Between Humor and History
While the enchanting antics of Juan Salvador are undeniably captivating, the film doesn’t shy away from addressing the darker undercurrents of Argentinian history during the 1976 coup. This dual narrative creates a bittersweet tone; one moment you are chuckling at the penguin’s charming mischief, and the next, you are reminded of the crushing political realities that hang over the story.
However, at times, this juxtaposition can feel jarring. The film’s heart tends to waver as it navigates the despair of a country in turmoil, often overshadowing the genuine warmth and humor that the bond between Tom and his penguin brings to the screen.
Final Thoughts
While "The Penguin Lessons" does a commendable job of highlighting the beauty of a unique friendship, it occasionally loses its balance between the adorable and the unsettling. The film shines brightest when it focuses on the whimsical charm of its feathered protagonist, reminding us of the power of love, friendship, and resilience.
Having premiered at the Toronto Film Festival in 2024, "The Penguin Lessons" opened in select theaters on March 28th, inviting audiences to join in on this delightful journey filled with laughter, nostalgia, and reflections on life amid chaos.
Explore More
Support local journalism and stay updated by subscribing to the Journal & Topics, available in both print and online formats.
